Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Simon Pearce's avatar

Balaji, I want to be on board with this. Truly. But I have to be honest: I have some serious reservations.

There’s a clarity to your vision that’s undeniably compelling, but it also feels, at times, too neat. Too clean. It carries the scent of High Modernism, with its promise of total legibility and systemic elegance. And like all High Modernist architectures, it risks collapsing into a Ballardian dystopia (see Super-Cannes, one of his sharpest).

So yes: you’re right that cryptographic control of capital assets is coming. That part is nearly inevitable. But I’m worried you’re skipping over some deeper structural truths. I don’t raise these as gotchas. I’d genuinely welcome your perspective if I’m missing something.

Here are my core concerns:

1. Enforcement is not the same as legitimacy. The latter is messy, emergent, and computationally irreducible. It requires more than protocol adherence: it requires social trust, historical context, and moral weight.

2. Protocols don’t eliminate coercion, they obscure it. Code may execute deterministically, but the choice of what gets encoded is political. Who interprets edge cases? Who operates at the “sharp end” of protocol enforcement if not humans?

3. Coherence doesn’t emerge from code, it emerges from context. We live in a computationally irreducible universe (per Stephen Wolfram). You can’t shortcut your way to meaning by scaling enforcement. The more totalizing the system, the more brittle its failures.

In Decentralization and Its Discontents I explore how systems of control mutate as they decentralize. I suspect you’ll find the critique familiar, and perhaps worth wrestling with, especially if you’ve read Venkatesh Rao’s deep dives on decentralization as a metatribe. [If not, he’s on here and worth engaging with.]

I don’t need to be right for the sake of it. But I do think we need more debate at this level of depth: not just about what crypto can do, but about what it means.

Looking forward to your thoughts.

https://open.substack.com/pub/theliminallens/p/crypto-decentralization-belief-engine?r=dvftt&utm_medium=ios

Expand full comment
Sundeep Bajikar's avatar

Great articulation of what’s to come. Tokenization of everything will require a lot of semiconductors and a lot of electricity!

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts